India - Is future promise worth the wait?
from Peter Schmidt -
February 19th 2014
Demand is not only the stored up desire to own something, but also the willingness and ability to pay for it.
India clearly scores high on the former, but less so on the second.
Recent developments in Indiaís car market have been disappointing.
Whilst Indiaís own Tata has already run aground, Hyundai has continued to sail on serenely.
But there is no knowing the extent of its recent sales push efforts.
Indiaís car market had been touted to become a significant growth market thanks to its impressive growth record and above all its vast population.
But far from following the same or even remotely similar path as China, which continues to forge ahead at a faster than earlier predicted pace, so far at least, Indiaís car market continues to languish in the starting blocks.
Moreover, while Chinaís car sales mix has turned out a great deal richer than even optimists could have expected during the late 1990s, Indiaís new car market consists almost entirely of inexpensive small cars with few frills.
Yet paradoxically, the cheapest car yet devised by the industry for just such a market - the previously much talked about Tata Nano - stands out as a high-profile flop.
Contrast that with Suzukiís long trusted tiny cars that are still responsible for half the cars sold there.
Last yearís Suzukiís sales share rose 6 percentage points, while Fordís car sales share in India almost halved, slipping to a mere 2.5 per cent from 4.3 per cent only the year before.
Moreover, Nissan, after only recently entering Indiaís car market with high hopes, appears to be doing little better than Ford. It too suffered a devastating 47.1 per cent dip in last yearís sales, chopping its market share to 1.3 per cent from 2.2 per cent only the year before.
The bare knuckle fist fight for sales is such that even Skoda, a comparatively long established campaigner in India, saw last yearís sales plunge by more than a third to some 20,700 units.
So how about a recent arrival such as Volkswagen?
Last December it assembled just over 4,000 of its cars in India.
The vast majority of these - 3,800 - went for export.
It suggests that the bulk of its December sales in India - 3,000 - came from bulging stocks of unsold cars.
Compare that with China.
By measure of magnitude, in China the VW brand sold almost quarter of a million cars last December alone, made up in the main of Golf-class cars.
Chinaís car market went from strength to strength, with annual passenger car sales zooming from less than a million as recently as 2001 to 3.2m in 2005 and a sky-high 14.8m last year.
While China continued to steam on at express pace during recent years, Indiaís car market, after growing encouragingly during the mid to late 2000s, has clearly hit the buffers.
In the early to mid 2000s, India was selling around 800,000 passenger cars per year.
Following encouraging growth since then, today India sells closer to two million cars.
Even without imports, last yearís new car sales in China rose by 2.3 million to 14.8 million units.
In India, it is not only foreign carmakers that are now taking a beating.
Long established domestics are also suffering.
None more so than Tata.
Its woes are summed up by the sobering realisation that it currently ranks as the marketís biggest casualty.
Last yearís domestic car sales more than halved to less than 108,000 units.
Its full year market share slumped to 5.9 per cent from 11.6 per cent only the year before.
Clearly, with few notable exceptions such as Hyundai, which also ranks as Indiaís way and ahead biggest exporter of cars, most of Indiaís terrified autoindustry is now saddled with a huge chunk of idling surplus capacity.
Adding to their misery, the recent steep slide of Indiaís rupee on currency exchange markets has greatly inflated the cost of vital imported parts and major assemblies from their plants in dollar or euro regions.
A survey of the winners and losers in Indiaís bloody car sales wars shows that even some of the companies that acted early and aggressively to set up their stalls in India have not been spared the piercing pain from todayís fallout.
On the bright side however, there is a broad consensus that the available opportunities offered in Indiaís market in the medium to long term are worth the pain and bloodletting suffered at present.
At least for those who can afford to take the hit.
To an extent however, in light of recent setbacks, Indiaís stalled car market has echoes of Brazil, which was long seen as the country of the future.
As with Brazil, for India too no one really knows when that future really comes.
Judged from recent developments, itís probably wise to prepare for a long
| Troubled Tata falls back to earth 18 Feb 2014
Indiaís car sales just keep tumbling
12 Feb 2014
| BMW is right to have a foot in both camps, payback may take longer
18 Dec 2013
Please note that
eagleAID.com is a subscriber-only site, and as such it can
only be viewed by subscribers to the newsletter.